Wix, Squarespace, or a custom site: which should a local contractor use?
If you're just starting out and need something online this week, Wix or Squarespace is genuinely fine: a clean builder site beats no site, and it beats an expensive site you can't afford yet. But for an established contractor whose jobs are worth thousands of dollars, the builder becomes a ceiling: the sites are heavier and slower than hand-built pages, you can't fully control the technical structure Google and AI assistants read, and you're renting your presence on a platform you can never leave with your site intact. Builders aren't bad. They're a ceiling, and the trades hit it earlier than most businesses because local rankings are won on exactly the things builders limit.
When a builder is honestly the right call
New business, tight budget, no web presence at all: use the builder, today. A Squarespace site with your real photos, plain descriptions of your services, your phone number, and a link to your Google Business Profile puts you ahead of half the trades in any Seminole County town. Anyone who tells a brand-new operator they need a five-figure custom build before their first job is selling, not advising. Get the builder site up, pour your energy into reviews and your profile, and revisit when the jobs are coming in.
Where the ceiling bites
Builder pages carry the platform's whole toolkit to every visitor, which is why they're consistently heavier and slower on phones than a purpose-built page, and speed is a ranking input and a bounce factor. Structure is the bigger limit: competitive local SEO runs on dedicated service-and-city pages, clean structured data, and full technical control, and builders let you approximate this but never own it. And there's the sameness problem: when your $80,000-kitchen prospect lands on a template they've subconsciously seen forty times, the site reads as smaller than your work.
You'll notice you can't name a market leader in a competitive trade running on a stock Wix template. That's not snobbery; it's what the constraint does at the top of the market.
The exit problem, and how to decide
The quiet catch with every builder: you can't take the site with you. Leave the platform and you leave with your text and images at best; the site itself, and often the momentum it earned, stays behind. A custom-built site is files you own, portable to any host on earth.
So the decision is a stage question, not a brand question. Getting started or web presence isn't yet a growth lever: builder, no shame in it. Established, high-ticket, and losing searches to competitors who invested: the custom build stops being a luxury and starts being the cheaper option per job it wins.
Related answers, tools, and proof.
Got a question we haven’t answered?
Ask us directly: a real person answers, and we’ll give you the same straight version you just read, applied to your business. Or start with a free grade of where your site stands.